Why Business is like a Religious Calling?

Although Novak merely writes off this incident as an illustration of Carnegie's imperfection, the facts given by Novak about Carnegie's behavior reflect the latter's treachery and hypocrisy in his treatment of workers. For example, based on Novak, Carnegie deliberately instructed his local manager to crush the union, although this sort of a tactic violated the principles about labor he had proclaimed in public. Furthermore, he left Pittsburgh inside height from the crisis for Scotland and distanced himself during the action of his subordinates whilst he was fully aware of them (Novak 62). Ironically, Novak's profile of Carnegie as an impressive businessman, who produced great wealth through innovation and improved the welfare from the poor, is severely tainted by his detailed account in the Homestead episode. Apparently, Novak doesn't take into account Carnegie's deceptive suppression on the workers a significant ample incident to mar the reader's impression of the good Carnegie.

Furthermore, Novak's portrayal in the successful American society, propelled forward by the burgeoning economy (91) omits particular sectors of society, which have not benefited inside "social mobility, opportunity, as well as the pursuit of own accomplishment" (91). Some of these neighborhoods include the inner city neighbor hoods inhabited by minority groups and immigrants, ravaged by crime and poverty. During the same way, Novak's logical statement that firm corporations don't oppress individuals who work for them because they know it's "morally inadmissible" (126) is each blind for the harsh simple fact confronted by minority groups and women. Women and minority groups encounter glass ceilings and discrimination in their workplace. Several of them are not fulfilled in their jobs, nor do they discover their jobs environment pleasant. In spite of numerous changes, these barriers remain a concrete reality.

What truly betrays Novak's conservative bent for the business community are his statements against the government's social policies. In his general description about changes that come in society, Novak attributes the rise in out-of-wedlock births to one reason the creation with the welfare method (68). This paragraph jumps out at the reader since it attacks the welfare procedure without the need of providing sufficient reasons. Instead, this blanket statement is buried between other examples of adverse social changes that have occurred throughout the world.

Finally, his guidance to rich businessmen and their trustees that they need to not donate to universities and entities, which oppose their capitalistic objectives (Novak 201), reveals his belief in ideological hegemony. However, his stance goes against his stated belief about the significance of democracy. Earlier during the text, Novak concedes that there are many "sinners from the [capitalist] system" (68); thus, it's crucial that you will find other "social structures that promote?virtuous behavior" (Novak 69).

 

Ordercustompaper.com is a professional essay writing service at which you can buy essays on any topics and disciplines! All custom essays are written by professional writers!